Welcome to Penny's Candy Company!

Who we are

Penny's Candy Company is a special addition to our Ice Cream Parlor Zems, it was opened and named after one of the owners, "Penny". We decided our town needed a place for our community to get ice cream products after we closed Zems for the season.

A place to get premium chocolates, and nostalgic candy you may not be able to get at the grocery store. We wanted to give an old-fashioned candy shop feel, and a place for people to reminisce and create new memories. We keep expanding year after year, adding more to our Candy Shop Portfolio.

Currently we make our own Fudge. Sell Asher's Premium Chocolates and have new & old-fashioned candy. We have an entire Bakery with homemade items to choose from, and a freezer full of our homemade ice cream cakes, pies, sandwiches and much more!

Each Holiday Season, we have specialty items we make and bring in from other local vendors. If you haven't been in to see what we offer, stop in and visit us and go back in time - like a kid in a candy store!
Sincerely, Penny, Rick, & Meghan

We also added a Dairy Cooler with Canastota Dairy Products, including their 2 lb. Premium Butter (formerly Queensboro), and many more dairy options to choose from.