Perfect Gift Or Treat Yourself

Home Made Fudge

Delicious home made fudge made fresh every day. From classic creamy chocolate fudge to caramel fudge, raspberry chocolate fudge, and penuchi fudge. We also have many other flavors including peanut butter, peanut butter chocolate, orange cream fudge, maple walnut, & cookies and cream fudge and many more.

Fudge trays are also available for a party or group occasion. You won't be disappointed with the quality or multiple selections!

Classic Home Made Chocolates

Our turtles are made with creamy milk chocolate, topped with pecans and soft caramel. We also offer classic peanut clusters, milk cashew clusters and milk almond clusters.

Asher's Chocolates

Asher's is a family owned chocolate company and has been open since 1892! Keeping the recipe the same as it goes through different generations. From their family to ours, and now to yours!

Novelty & Miscellaneous Candy

Remember when you could get those? You still can! Here you will find early candies like they used to make in the good old days. Novelty candy and other candy you don't normally find available online.

About Us

Welcome to our website. We are a locally owned and family operated establishment in Canastota, NY. If you are within driving distance, you are cordially invited to stop in during business hours for a treat you won't soon forget. Penny's Candy Company is located at ZEMS Ice Cream Stand.

"Where old memories are brought to life and new memories are made."

We are active community supporters and believe in the old fashioned values; 'do unto others as you would have them do unto you'. We treat every customer with respect and prompt friendly service.